Judges Upset at Ohio Prisons for Rejecting Commitments

THE BEST OF: The following article, published on March 11, 2012, reflects a telling change in perspective of some judges and state prison officials, as it relates to who goes to prison and who remains in the community

An interesting story out of Ohio is making waves across the nation (see Facebook collumn on the far right), describes a conflict between some Ohio judges and the Ohio Department Rehabilitation and Corrections. Under a statute that became law last October, Corrections is not required to accept 4th and 5th degree felons (less serious offenders) who are sentenced to prison for the first time. The Department can reject the court’s sentence  and the court must then sentence the felon to community corrections programs, available in their community, before they may send them to state prison. The story suggests that Drug Court might be an alternative the court is required to try before sending a felony drug offender to prison.

The law and its application presents some interesting issues. Does the statute invade the Courts perrogative as an independent, and equal division of state government. Will the Ohio Corrections’ decision not to accept a less serious offender into prison, improperly limit the court’s discretion to sentence as he/she believes appropriate.

These are clearly important questions. The fact that they are being considered at all is a mark of the progress we’ve made in just a few years. For the first time, governors, legislatures, and Departments of Corrections are willing to reject a prison sentence. The reason for the rejection is equally important; the judge in the opinion of Prison Authorities have not given the felon an adequate opportunity to work with community corrections and other prison alternatives in their own community before a prison sentence is ordered.

How times have changed!

EXTRA: Importance of Supreme Court Ruling on ACA

Breaking News/July 2, 1012
Former ONDCP Deputy Director Thomas McLellan, describing the impact of the ACA , concludes that the requirement that care services for the full range of substance use disorders be part of the law’s “essential benefit design”, is a  sign of the historic changes to come in our treatment of drug abusers in this country.

Philadelphia; June 29, 2012: A. Thomas McLellan, PhD, CEO of the Treatment Research Institute, and former Deputy Director of the Obama Office of National Drug Control Policy (serving on the Obama Healthcare Reform Task Force), had the following to say about impacts on the substance use/addiction field given the June 28, 2012 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court upholding the Constitutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act:

“The decision by the Supreme Court upholding the Constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is an extremely uplifting one for the substance abuse field. The debates and research around the ACA produced two facts that were startling to all involved.

First, unaddressed substance use now costs mainstream healthcare upwards of $100 billion annually, particularly in areas such as ER and trauma care, but also in the treatment of virtually every chronic illness. Because of the severity and complexity of their conditions, the 23 million “addicted” Americans are disproportionately costly – but it is the 40 – 45 million Americans with lower severity but still significant “harmful substance use disorders” who comprise the largest burden of illness and cost to healthcare.

 The second realization produced in the ACA debates is that while there is provision to treat “addiction” in specialty care programs (though clearly more coverage is needed) there had never been healthcare benefits or reimbursement options for those with “harmful substance use.”

 Thus, one of the historic aspects of ACA is the requirement that care services for the full range of substance use disorders be part of the “essential benefit design” in all health plans.

 This is the beginning of a new era in prevention, early intervention and office based care for patients who are not addicted – but whose drinking, smoking, and use of other substances is harming their health and compromising the effectiveness of the care they are receiving for other illnesses and conditions.”

© 2007 -  Reentry Court Solutions. All Rights Reserved.


Reentry Court Solutions Powered by Communications Team